As promised, a couple pictures. They're not too clear, but I think you guys will get the idea. I'm wondering if something else under the fender or bumper is bent because I can't even get the gap to close using my hands with substantial force. This is just what my budget needs... another repair that should have been completely avoidable.

[xx(]
It does appear to be a rivet of some sort that holds this part of the bumper to the vehicle...
__________________

2003 Classic Edition, 5-speed with 7-ball shift knob, badges removed, dark tint, Borla split exit exhaust, short billett antenna, Nu-Image white-faced blue flamed gauges and 15\" American Racing Aero Wheels.